Golden hour light on a quiet Detroit avenue
Azzo Legal Guides · Car Accidents

The Michigan Truck Accident Guide

Why a semi crash is its own fight, and the evidence that disappears in week one.

A semi crash is not a bigger car accident.

Truck and bus crashes, 2024
15888
involving heavy trucks and buses
People injured
3613
in those crashes
People killed
110
statewide

Source: Michigan Traffic Crash Facts, 2024 fact sheets.

The whole claim, in order

What should you do after a truck accident in Michigan?

Each step protects the next. Get medical care fast, open the claim on time, build the record, and settle once the record is complete.

01
The first 72 hours

Medical care first, then the scene

Get medical care today, even if you feel fine. Photograph everything at the scene if you can: both vehicles, the trailer's markings and DOT number, skid marks, the wider road. Get the police report number. Report the crash to your own insurer briefly and honestly. Do not give the trucking company's insurer a recorded statement. Its investigators are often working the scene before the tow truck leaves.

02
Week one

Send the preservation letter

Electronic logging data, dashcam footage, and driver logs get overwritten on a schedule, sometimes within days. A preservation letter in the first week forces the company to keep them. This is the single biggest reason truck cases reward early action. If you do nothing else this week, make sure someone sends that letter.

03
Your no-fault claim

Your own PIP benefits pay first

Like any Michigan crash, your own PIP benefits pay first: medical bills, wage loss, attendant care, mileage. File the application honestly, minimally, and on time.

04
The trucking claim

Find every company and every policy

The claim against the trucking side carries the real weight, and it often runs against more than one company: the driver, the carrier, the broker, the maintenance contractor, sometimes the loader. Each brings its own policy, and finding every policy is a large part of what the case is worth.

05
Building the claim

Trucking insurers price claims on preparation

Several of the strongest levers are ready early: preserved logs, complete policies, a clean treatment record. If your case is not worth pursuing, we say so and tell you what to do instead.

Taking notes on a legal pad beside a phone in warm window light
Write it down while it is fresh. The logs you start in week one are the ones that pay in month six.
Deadlines

How long do you have after a truck accident in Michigan?

Every injury claim in Michigan has deadlines that start the day you are hurt. The forms are short. Missing a date can end the claim.

Your deadlines

Time from the crash to each cutoff. The facts of your case can shift these dates. A consultation confirms which ones apply to you.

Preservation letter
electronic logs get overwritten in days
Week 1
8
Day 1
PIP one-year-back rule
late filing shrinks what you can recover
1 year
33
1 year
Suit against the trucking side
statute of limitations
3 years
99
3 years
CrashYear 1Year 2Year 3
Starting early costs less. Evidence scatters, witnesses move, and the one-year-back rule cuts what a late claim can recover.
What your case is worth

What moves a Michigan truck accident claim?

Economic damages are added up from bills, receipts and lost pay. Pain and suffering has no formula. Each side argues a number from your medical record, and the multipliers you see online have no force in a Michigan court.

What raises value ↑

  • A preservation letter locking down logs and dashcam footage
  • Photos of the trailer's markings and DOT number
  • Every policy found, from carrier to broker to loader
  • Medical care the same day, treated consistently
  • Objective injuries a scan or an X-ray can show
  • Consistent treatment with no gaps
  • Credible witnesses and clean scene photos
  • A counteroffer backed by records
  • A lawyer the insurer believes will try the case

What lowers it ↓

  • A recorded statement given to the trucking insurer
  • Evidence overwritten while the claim waited
  • Gaps between crash and treatment
  • Missed one-year-back and retention windows
  • Gaps in treatment the insurer reads as recovery
  • Social media posts that contradict your injury claim
  • Recorded statements given early and casually
  • Prior injuries hidden instead of disclosed
  • Deadlines missed while the claim waited

Where Michigan's 2024 crashes came from

Reported contributing factors, statewide. The other driver's behavior is often the heart of the fault argument.

Distracted driving
0
Alcohol involved
0
Drug involved
0

Source: Michigan State Police 2024 year-end crash data.

Ask Azzo

Questions people ask

Who pays my medical bills after a truck accident in Michigan?

Your own auto insurer pays first, through your no-fault PIP coverage, no matter who caused the crash. How much it pays depends on the coverage level someone in your household selected when buying the policy. MCL 500.3107c. The claim against the driver and the trucking companies is a separate case, with its own deadline.

What evidence disappears first?

Electronic logging data, dashcam footage, and driver logs get overwritten on a schedule, sometimes within days. Federal record-retention windows are shorter than any lawsuit deadline. A preservation letter in the first week forces the company to keep them.

Do I need a lawyer for a truck accident?

Trucking insurers price claims on preparation. Several of our attorneys came from the insurance defense side and know how these claims get valued. If your case is not worth pursuing, we say so and tell you what to do instead.

News

Recent rulings that changed Michigan truck claims

In May 2026 the Supreme Court held that a freight broker can be sued for negligently hiring an unsafe carrier. The Sixth Circuit, which covers Michigan, got there ten months earlier. Six decisions, newest first, on brokers, carriers, owner liability, and the no-fault threshold.

Updated

July 28, 2026

In May 2026 the Supreme Court ruled unanimously that a freight broker can be sued for negligently hiring an unsafe carrier. The Sixth Circuit, which covers Michigan, had reached the same answer ten months earlier. That changes who can end up in a Michigan truck case. Here is that ruling and five others that shape a claim now, newest first.

Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC, 2026

Supreme Court of the United States, decided May 14, 2026, 608 U.S. ___ (2026) (No. 24-1238)

Shawn Montgomery was driving a tractor trailer when another truck hit him. He was left with severe and permanent injuries. The other driver was hauling a load of plastic pots through Illinois for Caribe Transport II, a motor carrier. A freight broker, C.H. Robinson, had arranged the shipment. Montgomery sued the broker too. His claim was that Robinson knew or should have known from the carrier's safety rating that putting it on the road was reasonably likely to hurt someone.

The district court threw that claim out. It ruled that the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, which blocks state laws related to trucking prices, routes and services, preempted the negligent hiring claim. The Seventh Circuit agreed. The Supreme Court reversed, unanimously, in an opinion by Justice Barrett.

The Court held that the statute's safety exception saves the claim. States keep their authority to regulate safety "with respect to motor vehicles," and the Court read that phrase to mean a claim that concerns the vehicles used in transportation. Asking a broker to use ordinary care when it picks a carrier concerns the trucks that haul the load. The Court was careful about the edges. State laws about prices, routes and services with no relationship to safety stay preempted.

For an injured person in Michigan, this settles a question that had split the federal courts for years. The broker who selected the carrier is no longer outside the case on preemption grounds alone.

Cox v. Total Quality Logistics, Inc., 2025

United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, decided July 8, 2025, 142 F.4th 847

Greta Cox died in a crash. Her husband, Robert Cox, sued Total Quality Logistics, the freight broker, for negligently hiring an unsafe motor carrier. A federal district court dismissed the case on preemption, the same reasoning that had sunk claims like it elsewhere.

The Sixth Circuit reversed. Writing for the panel, Judge Stranch worked through it in two steps. First, the court agreed the claim falls inside the statute's preemptive reach, which lined it up with every circuit that had looked at the question. Then it turned to the safety exception and found the claim survives there. Common law duties are part of a state's authority to regulate safety. And a negligent hiring claim against a broker is "with respect to motor vehicles," because the exception describes which state laws stay alive, not which companies can be sued.

The Sixth Circuit covers Michigan. Federal judges in the Eastern and Western Districts of Michigan follow it. This decision landed roughly ten months before the Supreme Court reached the same conclusion, which means Michigan claimants were already on the better side of the split.

Andary v. USAA Casualty Insurance Company, 2023

Michigan Supreme Court, decided July 31, 2023, Andary v. USAA Casualty Insurance Company, Docket No. 164772

Ellen Andary and Philip Krueger were both catastrophically hurt in motor vehicle crashes before 2019. Under the no-fault act and the policies in force back then, they had uncapped lifetime medical care paid through personal protection insurance. Then in 2019 the Legislature rewrote the no-fault act. The new version of MCL 500.3157 sharply cut reimbursable hours for attendant care provided by family members and capped rates for services Medicare does not cover. Their insurers moved to apply the new limits to them.

The Michigan Supreme Court said no. In an opinion by Justice Welch, joined by Chief Justice Clement and Justices Bernstein, Cavanagh and Bolden, the Court held that the 2019 amendments do not reach care that was already being provided and already reimbursable before the amendments passed. Their rights to those benefits were contractual as well as statutory, and the amendments did not retroactively modify vested contractual rights. The Court dismissed the separate constitutional challenges to applying the amendments going forward.

Truck crashes produce the kind of injuries this case is about. Attendant care, home modifications, decades of treatment. Under Andary, the date of the crash matters to what an insurer owes.

McCormick v. Carrier, 2010

Michigan Supreme Court, decided July 31, 2010, 487 Mich 180; 795 NW2d 517

Michigan no-fault limits when an injured person can sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering. You have to clear the threshold in MCL 500.3135, which the statute calls a serious impairment of body function. For six years, a 2004 decision called Kreiner v. Fischer had read that threshold narrowly, and a lot of real injuries did not clear it.

The Court overruled Kreiner. Justice Cavanagh wrote that Kreiner departed from the plain language of the statute, and that its list of extra factors and its near-permanency requirement were not in the text at all. The Court laid out the three prongs the statute actually sets: an objectively manifested impairment, of an important body function, that affects the person's general ability to lead his or her normal life.

Then it applied that test. The plaintiff broke his ankle, could not put weight on it for a month, had two surgeries across ten months and did not return to work for 19 months. The Court held he met the threshold as a matter of law. Michigan courts still use that test, and in most truck injury suits it is the first fight.

Hashem v. Les Stanford Oldsmobile, Inc, 2005

Michigan Court of Appeals, decided June 7, 2005, 266 Mich App 61; 697 NW2d 558

In July 1999 a car owned by a dealership, driven by an intoxicated teenager, struck the rear of a tractor trailer on I-75 and flipped. Ronny Hashem died. A jury returned $12 million in noneconomic damages on the wrongful death claim. The trial court had directed a verdict for the party store that sold the alcohol, and it made the dealership jointly and severally liable for the entire judgment.

The Court of Appeals reversed and remanded on both of those rulings. Judge Hoekstra's opinion treated one point as undisputed along the way. As the owner of the vehicle, the dealership was statutorily liable under MCL 257.401(1) for damages caused by negligent operation, even though it was not driving.

That owner liability statute is a large part of why the company whose name rides on the trailer can end up in a Michigan truck case. Hashem also shows the second half of the problem. Establishing liability and deciding how a judgment gets split among the responsible parties are two separate fights.

Rogers v. J B Hunt Transport, Inc, 2002

Michigan Supreme Court, decided July 23, 2002, 466 Mich 645; 649 NW2d 23

On a June afternoon in 1996, Daimon Rogers left westbound I-96 in Eaton County and struck a tractor trailer parked on the north shoulder. He did not survive. J.B. Hunt owned the rig, and its driver had been working in the course of his employment. Hunt answered the lawsuit and denied negligence. The driver never appeared, and he failed to show for depositions across fourteen months. The court defaulted him.

The estate argued that the default settled the carrier's liability too, since a default conclusively established the driver's negligence and the carrier answers for its driver. The trial court and the Court of Appeals agreed.

The Michigan Supreme Court reversed. Justice Weaver wrote that a default entered against an employee, which conclusively determines that employee's negligence for his own personal liability, is not a proper foundation for an order holding the employer vicariously liable. The Court noted the driver's alleged negligence had never actually been litigated, and it expressed no opinion on the merits of negligence or causation.

A driver who disappears does not decide the carrier's case. The proof still has to be built against the company.

If a commercial truck hurt you or someone in your family, the questions in these cases are the questions your claim will run into. Who was the carrier. Who brokered the load. What your policy said on the day of the crash. You can call Azzo Law at 844-ASK-AZZO, which is 844-275-2996. Intake will take your information and route your question to the right person at the firm. No pressure, and no cost to ask.

Lauren Sitto Azzo, lead attorney at Azzo Law, PLLC, is responsible for the content of this page. This section is general information about Michigan court decisions and not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.

What happens when you call?

Tell us what happened, online or at 844-ASK-AZZO. Your attorney calls you back, usually the same day. If your case is not worth pursuing, we say so and tell you what to do instead.

Tell us what happened

Or call 844-ASK-AZZO (844-275-2996) · Free consultation, no fee unless we win on personal injury cases

Tell us what happened

Answer a few short questions and tell your story from wherever you are. Your answers go straight to the team, and sending them commits you to nothing.